A-score (21.1): Violence driver maxed (5) for 58 deaths. Civil_rights high (4.5) for humanitarian/civilian targeting. Rule_of_law (3.5) for potential IHL violations at aid site. Capture (2) for US complicity angle. Corruption (1.5) for aid diversion concerns. Severity multipliers elevated for irreversible deaths (1.2), ongoing pattern (1.1), precedent of targeting aid infrastructure (1.1). Mechanism_modifier reduced (0.7) - no specific US constitutional mechanism identified, foreign military action. Scope international (1.1). Base 24.86 → Final 21.1. B-score (24.6): Layer1 high - outrage_bait (9) for civilian deaths at aid site, media_friendliness (8) for visual/emotional content, meme_ability (4), novelty (3) as continuation. Layer2 - mismatch (7) US-backed site attacked by US ally, pattern_match (7) fits Gaza coverage cycle, narrative_pivot (6) shifts to US complicity, timing (5) moderate. Intentionality (6) for 'US-backed' framing emphasis. D-score: -3.5. Both scores ~25 threshold, |D|<10 = Mixed classification. Real constitutional concerns (US foreign policy accountability, war crimes complicity) but also high emotional/political charge.