A-score: Separation of powers (3) reflects tension between executive appointment power and Senate's constitutional role in pro forma sessions. Capture (2) for personnel_capture mechanism with narrow scope. Rule_of_law (1) and corruption (1) for procedural manipulation claims. Severity multipliers near neutral (0.9*1.1*0.95=0.94). Mechanism modifier 1.15 for personnel_capture. Base: (0*0.22+1*0.18+3*0.16+0*0.14+2*0.14+1*0.10+0*0.06)*0.94*1.15*1.0=11.0. B-score: Layer1 (24.75/55%): High outrage_bait (6) for intraparty betrayal narrative, moderate media_friendliness (5), low novelty (3) as recess appointment debates are recurring. Layer2 (22/45%): High mismatch (7) between constitutional process framing and partisan complaint reality, narrative_pivot (6) creating GOP-vs-Trump storyline. Intentionality 6/15 (0.136 weight) for partisan framing and amplification of internal conflict without substantive evidence. Final: 24.75+22*1.136=27.4. D-score: -16.4 strongly favors List B classification.