Presidential commutation of fraud conviction scores moderately on constitutional damage. Rule_of_law (3.5): clemency power is constitutional but application to fraud conviction undermines justice system accountability. Separation (2): within executive authority but tests boundaries of clemency norms. Capture (3): personnel_capture mechanism confirmed, commutation of business fraud conviction suggests favoritism dynamics. Corruption (2.5): appearance of improper influence in clemency decision. Severity: durability 1.2 (precedent for future clemency), reversibility 0.9 (cannot be undone but individual case), precedent 1.0 (standard). Mechanism modifier 1.15 for personnel_capture. Scope 0.95 for federal/narrow. Base: (0×0.22 + 3.5×0.18 + 2×0.16 + 0×0.14 + 3×0.14 + 2.5×0.10 + 0×0.06)×1.1×1.15×0.95 = 19.88. B-score: Layer1 moderate (outrage over fraud commutation, some media coverage). Layer2: pattern_match high (fits clemency-for-allies narrative), timing/pivot low. Intentionality 6/15 (pattern visible, some strategic timing). Final 13.44. Delta +6.44 favors A but below +10 threshold. A-score below 25. Classification: List A (constitutional mechanism present, A>B, rule of law concerns).